Spider Mines Yey or nay?

Here's a specific forum for discussing potential maps, maps that need a vacation and optimizations and modifications for better playability.

Spider mines?

yey
8
53%
nay
7
47%
 
Total votes: 15
DW_Hornet
DW Clan Member
Posts: 1125
Joined: Mon Mar 13, 2006 12:00 am

Ok looking at these maps and tasked with it adjusting some lockers. Whats your view on spider mines. I hate to admit it but sometimes they can be useful. Spider mantaing a tank is sweet especially if vic is in it. So should they be bleached out of every map or placed sparingally in places?


Yes/No?
Bean
1337 Haxor
Posts: 252
Joined: Fri Jul 07, 2006 11:00 pm
Location: Po-dunk Idaho

Personally, I think it depends on which map you're talking about. If they're on maps specifically designed for spam such as Bitchslap or Dreamus, they're annoying. On the bigger maps that don't seem enclosed, I say go ahead.
DW_e_aLpHa
DW Clan Member
Posts: 733
Joined: Sun Apr 02, 2006 11:00 pm

I could play any map really happily with any mines at all -
..:: Sworn to a Secrecy ::..
Image
==||+ Beast Of Blood +||==
DW_KarmaKat
Site Admin
Posts: 2005
Joined: Thu Mar 23, 2006 12:00 am
Xfire: KarmaKat

Yah...keep the little buggers!

Agree that on spam maps they're more nuisance than helpful...I get tired of flakking or mini-ing them...when I'd rather have my ammo for a target that counts...like the back of someone's head! ::evil grin::

KKat
Karma...a term that comprises the entire cycle of cause & effect...
Kat...a supercilious quadrupedal pile of fur that doesn´t give a flying fig for Karma...
User avatar
DW_ACY
DW Clan Member
Posts: 860
Joined: Sat Jul 22, 2006 11:00 pm

I say keep them this Newb really needs some chance at taking down the pro's.
Image

No shame, no dishonor, will run away to fight another day!
ACY
Zax_Gentoo_Box
1337 Haxor
Posts: 497
Joined: Sun Jun 18, 2006 11:00 pm
Location: Caves of ice, Xanadu

Hmm.. sure. The game designers, in all their infinite wisdom, deemed to put them in the game. Put them with like 8 ammo, but no more than that. Mines really aren't a problem if you have a flak cannon, when they jump for the kill blow, just jump forward, reverse direction, and flak.
DW_Snaggle
DW Clan Member
Posts: 381
Joined: Fri Mar 24, 2006 12:00 am

Mines with grenade icing can take out just about anything. Fun to watch too. Big Bada Boom!

Snaggle.
Urtho
Camper
Posts: 96
Joined: Sat Jan 07, 2006 12:00 am

Can you guess how I voted?

When used in moderation and carefully placed in the right spot on a map they can be an ok addition. I'll never be a big fan of such a non-skill weapon but mines have their uses I'll freely admit and they are part of the game as Epic intended it. The thing I hate is when mappers put them in highly trafficed lockers like the ones in a base and then load them up with 16 mines as a default ammo count. That is insane with 32 players all having quick and easy acess to that many.

If you're going to use mines in your map, place them as a seperate pickup with low default ammo and then a pack or two of mine ammo right next to the weapon to allow for it to be used by a person only if they make a specific effort to get the weapon. One of the early attempts to fix Primeaval did it just right - it placed mine pickups at the elbow of the turn in the path from the cores to the center node. Not immediately available but still there if you wanted to take a few moments to pick them up. Reduced ammo counts also help cut down on the choppiness some maps suffer from as mines = lag for those who don't know.
DW_WailofSuicide
DW Clan Member
Posts: 1634
Joined: Wed Dec 28, 2005 12:00 am

Zax_Gentoo_Box wrote:Hmm.. sure. The game designers, in all their infinite wisdom, deemed to put them in the game. Put them with like 8 ammo, but no more than that. Mines really aren't a problem if you have a flak cannon, when they jump for the kill blow, just jump forward, reverse direction, and flak.
The same infinite wisdom that produced a whole slew of virtually unplayable ONS maps out of the box, the crazily powerful early version Raptors and Mantas, the excellent weapon balance, etc? Heh.

Did you know the Spider Mines were originally intended to latch onto a target and drain health from it (they're "Parasite" mines)? They never bothered finishing the mines and completing that functionality.
DW_ToxicWaste
Site Admin
Posts: 1060
Joined: Tue Dec 27, 2005 12:00 am

Urtho wrote:Can you guess how I voted?

When used in moderation and carefully placed in the right spot on a map they can be an ok addition. I'll never be a big fan of such a non-skill weapon but mines have their uses I'll freely admit and they are part of the game as Epic intended it. The thing I hate is when mappers put them in highly trafficed lockers like the ones in a base and then load them up with 16 mines as a default ammo count. That is insane with 32 players all having quick and easy acess to that many.

If you're going to use mines in your map, place them as a seperate pickup with low default ammo and then a pack or two of mine ammo right next to the weapon to allow for it to be used by a person only if they make a specific effort to get the weapon. One of the early attempts to fix Primeaval did it just right - it placed mine pickups at the elbow of the turn in the path from the cores to the center node. Not immediately available but still there if you wanted to take a few moments to pick them up. Reduced ammo counts also help cut down on the choppiness some maps suffer from as mines = lag for those who don't know.
+1

Although I will agree that mines do make new players feel a little more comfortable against better players and might allow for them to stick around more and get better, instead of just getting pounded and leaving.


Rich (TW)
Post Reply